Nagel's Protection
Spell Continuous

Nagel's Protection

  • Archetype:
  • Tindangle

  • View:
  • 2877




"Tindangle" monsters in your Main Monster Zones cannot be destroyed by battle or your opponent's card effects. Once per turn, if your "Tindangle" monster inflicts battle damage to your opponent, the damage is doubled. You can banish this card from your GY and discard 1 "Tindangle" card; add 1 "Nagel's Protection" from your Deck to your hand. You can only use this effect of "Nagel's Protection" once per turn.




 
 
AI Power Analysis
UtilityConfidence: MediumEvaluated Sep 1, 2025
38± 7/ 100
Power Score
Intrinsic 36
Deck 39

Nagel's Protection — Power Evaluation

Final Score: 38 ± 7 · Confidence: Medium

  • Intrinsic: 35.76 · Deck: 39.46 · Meta: provisional
  • Primary role: Utility · Secondary: Recovery/Recursion

Why it scores here

Nagel's Protection reliably converts into only one thing: a defensive aura for Tindangle boards that stops battle and effect destruction of your Tindangle Main Monster Zone monsters, plus a once-per-turn damage doubler and a GY effect that cycles a fresh copy for a discarded Tindangle. Combo evidence shows it is never a starter, material, payoff, or end-board piece (1 appearance, 0% in every structural role), so it adds no board presence and no disruption of its own. Its complete archetype lock and total lack of opponent interaction keep the weighted score low, and its stats (a Continuous Spell with 0 ATK/DEF) earn it nothing under this rubric.

Axis scores

Axis Score Evidence
Accessibility 40 Archetype-locked Continuous Spell with no shown generic searcher; practical access means drawing it or cycling a copy through its own GY effect (inferred).
Combo & Conversion 20 Combo evidence records 1 appearance with 0% as starter/material/payoff/end-board, so it builds nothing and only extends protection on an existing board (observed).
Resource Economy 45 Its GY effect banishes itself and discards 1 Tindangle card to add 1 'Nagel's Protection' from Deck, roughly an even trade that also recycles the card (verified).
Effect & Interaction 12 Text grants no negation, removal, or disruption of the opponent — only protection for your own Tindangle monsters (verified).
Material Utility 8 It is a Continuous Spell and cannot serve as monster material, so its body converts to nothing even when its effect is blanked (verified).
Resilience & Flexibility 48 It shields Tindangle Main Monster Zone monsters from battle and opponent's effect destruction across turns, but the Spell itself is removed by ordinary backrow hate (verified).
Deck-Building Efficiency 42 Runs at 2.47 average copies with no garnet, yet is dead outside the Tindangle archetype, which caps its slot efficiency (observed).

Calculation

Weight profile: 0.7 Utility + 0.3 Recovery/Recursion. Intrinsic ≈ 35.76, Deck ≈ 39.46, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck

Strengths

  • Blocks both battle destruction and opponent's effect destruction for Tindangle monsters in your Main Monster Zones.
  • Once per turn doubles battle damage dealt by a Tindangle monster, raising the clock when an attack connects.
  • GY effect lets it banish itself and discard 1 Tindangle card to fetch another copy, recycling the aura.

Weaknesses

  • Text is fully archetype-locked to 'Tindangle' monsters, so it is inert in any other deck.
  • Provides zero disruption, negation, or removal against the opponent.
  • The Spell itself has no protection and is removed by any backrow-hate card.
  • GY recursion requires discarding a Tindangle card, so it demands archetype fuel to function.
  • Damage-doubling clause is conditional on an unblocked Tindangle attack connecting.

Counters / choke points

  • Cosmic Cyclone / Mystical Space Typhoon / Twin Twisters chaining to remove the Continuous Spell.
  • Effects that banish or shuffle away your monsters rather than destroy them, which the protection does not stop.
  • Monster effect negation (e.g. Effect Veiler-style) on the attacking Tindangle blanks the damage-doubling clause.
  • Graveyard hate that empties the GY denies the self-recursion effect.

Best use

Defensive protection / archetype support. Decks: Tindangle. Suggested copies: 2.

Evidence & gaps

  • Verified: Card text: Tindangle monsters in your Main Monster Zones cannot be destroyed by battle or by your opponent's card effects.; Card text: once per turn, battle damage a Tindangle monster inflicts to your opponent is doubled.; Card text: you can banish this card from the GY and discard 1 Tindangle card to add 1 'Nagel's Protection' from Deck to hand; once per turn.; Card identity: Continuous Spell, Tindangle archetype, legal in TCG / OCG / Master Duel / Duel Links.
  • Observed: 34 decks in the sample run it, averaging 2.47 copies, with 67.6% of those lists inside Tindangle.; Combo evidence: 1 appearance with 0% as starter, 0% as material, 0% as payoff, 0% in end board.; Top partners are 100% Tindangle cards (Dholes, Base Gardna, Jhrelth, Intruder, Delaunay, Acute Cerberus).
  • Inferred: Archetype-locked text makes it non-splashable; only Tindangle decks can use the protection effect.; With no opponent interaction it cannot convert disruption into value; it only preserves an existing board.; Access to a first copy depends on drawing it or recycling it through its own GY effect; no searcher for it appears in evidence.
  • Data gaps: no banlist token — assumed 3 copies (unlimited) no usage statistics (StatisticsCard) — archetype inclusion % inferred from deck sample only combos evidence is a single recorded combo, so no reliable structural-role data no evidence on how often the destruction protection is actually relevant in games











https://metaduelist.com/
Top